2013
Fran Bolletino (Jr.)- Div. 2 EIVA Central All-star
- Honorable Mention Div. 3 All-American
Andy Buss (Jr.)- Div. 1 All-EIVA
Mike DeGrazia (Soph.)- Div. 2 All-EIVA
Danny Osterhout (Sr.)- Div. 1 EIVA Central All-star
- Div. 1 All-EIVA
Jharred Tulloch (Sr.)- Div. 2 EIVA Central All-star
Darin Van Horn (Sr.)- Div. 1 EIVA Central All-star
Jordan Wingenroth (Sr.)- Div. 2 EIVA MVP


2012
Andy Buss (Soph.)- Div. 1 All-EIVA
Andrew Hinton (Jr.)- EIVA Central D1 MVP
Steve Semler (Sr.)- Honorable Mention Div. 1 All-American
- Div. 1 EIVA MVP
Tyler Still (Sr.)- Div. 1 All-EIVA
Jordan Wingenroth (Jr.)- Honorable Mention Div. 3 All-American
Sean Zortman (Soph.)- Div. 2 All-EIVA


2011
Austin Overmeyer (Gr.)- Honorable Mention Div. 1 All-American
- Div. 1 All-EIVA MVP
Steve Semler (Jr.)- Div. 1 All-EIVA
Tyler Still (Jr.)- Div. 1 All-EIVA
Josh Wingenroth (Sr.)- EIVA Central D1 MVP